Skip to content
Advertisement
When Appliance Fail?

Chris Mason: The challenge of closing asylum loopholes while protecting genuine cases

There has been a stickiness to the electorate's concerns about issues of immigration and asylum, Chris Mason writes.

schedule 05:02 visibility 92 views
Chris Mason: The challenge of closing asylum loopholes while protecting genuine cases
BBC News Source: BBC News

At the heart of the arguments that rage around immigration and asylum are two of the most potent ideas in politics: fairness and control.

A perceived absence of either, let alone both, is potentially toxic and particularly so around issues as salient and often divisive as how many people, and who, should be invited to live here and remain here - and on what basis.

A tracker poll by YouGov suggests immigration and asylum have been seen by many over the last 15 years as among the most important issues facing the country, alongside the economy and the health service.

Think about that: in that time we have had the Brexit referendum and the Conservatives, Liberal Democrats and Labour in government at Westminster.

In other words, while plenty, outwardly, has changed, there has been a stickiness to the electorate's concern about these issues and, it seems reasonable to deduce, a persistent sense of governments, plural, failing to grip them.

That is why this BBC investigation is so significant. We are used to seeing one very visible element of many asylum claims – those arriving across the English Channel on small boats.

What this exposé casts a light upon is a much less visible element. You can read the first part of Billy Kenber and Phil Kemp's reporting here.

And you can read the second part here.

People in government tell me they were aware of this cheating and point to a change in the law coming next week that, they claim, will make it easier to withdraw support and accommodation from claimants who can be proved to be fraudulent and after that they would face deportation.

Ministers are also not ruling out closing down visa routes where it is clear a disproportionate number later go on to claim asylum fraudulently. Let's see.

In response to the BBC's investigation, Reform UK have said that if they were in government they would make facilitating a false asylum claim what is known as a "strict liability offence", meaning there would be no requirement to prove intent in prosecutions.

Ignorance, in other words, would not count as a defence.

Meanwhile, the Conservatives said the BBC's reporting had exposed a "racket", the Liberal Democrats said it was "abhorrent".

But the question now is: can loopholes be closed while protecting the genuinely vulnerable?

Plus, crucially, can this government and its successors, in their management of immigration and asylum, demonstrate the necessary fairness and control?

Legal advisers help migrants pose as gay to get asylum, undercover BBC investigation finds

Watch: Reporter told to pose as gay for asylum claim

Bogus websites, staged protests and pretend atheists: Inside the fake asylum industry

Mahmood promises action against 'sham lawyers' abusing asylum system

Track UK's latest migration numbers - including asylum, visas and small boats

BBC News

Originally published at

BBC News

open_in_new Read Full Article

Related Articles

Россия нанесла удар около границы Украины с Польшей, пострадал поезд на линии, которой пользуются западные лидеры. Что известно
World

Россия нанесла удар около границы Украины с Польшей, пострадал поезд на линии, которой пользуются западные лидеры. Что известно

В воскресенье российские военные нанесли удары беспилотниками по нескольким объектам, расположенным вблизи границы Украины с Польшей. В числе прочего пострадал локомотив поезда Киев — Варшава на железнодорожной станции Ягодин в Волынской области —...

BBC Russian
مواعيد وجباتك قد تؤثر في قلبك.. والخطر أكبر لدى الرجال!
World

مواعيد وجباتك قد تؤثر في قلبك.. والخطر أكبر لدى الرجال!

هل تُغير مواعيد وجباتك في عطلة نهاية الأسبوع؟ قد لا يكون الأمر مجرد اختلاف بسيط في الروتين، فقد ربطت دراسة بين اضطراب مواعيد تناول الطعام وبعض أمراض القلب، لا سيما لدى الرجال. لكن ما علاقة ذلك بالساعة البيولوجية؟

DW Arabic

Read More

ترامب يتوقع متى ستكون نهاية الحرب وبزشكيان: "إيران لن تستسلم أبدا"
World

ترامب يتوقع متى ستكون نهاية الحرب وبزشكيان: "إيران لن تستسلم أبدا"

أكد الرئيس الإيراني، بزشكيان، صمود الشعب الإيراني ورفضه لسياسات القوة والترهيب، مشددا على أن "إيران لن تستسلم". والرئيس الأمريكي ترامب يقول إن "إيران ترغب بشدة في التوصل إلى ‌اتفاق"، ويتوقع متى ستكون نهاية هذه الحرب.

DW Arabic
Spiegel: Советник Мерца был в одном из поездов у украинско-польской границы во время атаки РФ
World

Spiegel: Советник Мерца был в одном из поездов у украинско-польской границы во время атаки РФ

Ближайший советник канцлера ФРГ Фридриха Мерца, европейские чиновники и бывший премьер Великобритании Борис Джонсон находились в одном из поездов у украинско-польской границы во время атаки РФ, пишет Der Spiegel.

DW Russian
Кремль: Переговоры США, РФ и Украины могут пройти в октябре
World

Кремль: Переговоры США, РФ и Украины могут пройти в октябре

По словам пресс-секретаря президента РФ Дмитрия Пескова, переговоры с участием США, России и Украины с целью мирного урегулирования возможны в обозримой перспективе. Кушнер считает, что необходимо креативное решение.

DW Russian
Your Appliance Broke?
Reliable Repair for